Members
Five members are in the running for most talk time (preliminary)
Preliminary: at least 74% of members’ talk time is identified, under the 80% for a full comparison. The five in the running each average 2.6 to 5.1 minutes a meeting, and each could rank first; the data can’t order them.At least 74% of members’ talk time here is identifiedPreliminary: under 80% of talk time is identified.
74% identified80% for a full comparison
Member0246810min a meeting
Patrick CarneyArchitecture2.61.6–4.3 · voice identified in 18 of 44
Above: could rank first in talk time
Runs the meetingsOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicMembers · listed by seatOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topicOpen their page: every clip, meeting and topic
“Voice identified” counts the meetings where we could attribute a member’s voice. A meeting missing there means we couldn’t attribute it, not that they were absent.Chuck CollinsCommission President · runs the meetings6.1min of talk time a meetingRuns the meetings, so not comparedVoice identified at 22 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking6.1 min of talk time a meetingRuns the meetings, so not compared.38 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Three of their clips
So, so I think the question that we’re going to ask is, what is the process of engagement of the members of this commission physically in a space that we will share so that those goals can be discussed?”
When they issue bonds, bonds are allocated for the art, but also a portion for the care of the art during a finite period. Is that correct?”
Lydia SoSeat 5 · Commissioner ex officio0.9min of talk time a meetingSeated for only five meetings in 12 monthsVoice identified at 1 of 5 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking0.9 min of talk time a meetingSeated for only five meetings in 12 months.1 question asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
JD BeltranVisual Arts · Commissioner3.0min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 18 of 42 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking3.0 min of talk time a meeting90% range 1.9 to 4.9 minutes, over 42 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.40 questions asked
Their top topics
Arts, culture and libraries92%
Share of the time they spoke, by topic. Only topics that passed our check.Three of their clips
In the stated motion, it says enter into agreement with the San Francisco Symphony to support 1 free outdoor concert and 12 live performances. Are the 12 live performances also free?”
I just want to make one more comment that you may not notice unless you look at it more carefully. And I think one of the things that appealed to us was the major central image is actually of a parent throwing a child up in the sky.”
J. Riccardo BenavidesCommissioner0.1min of talk time a meeting7–12 of 12place in talk time, as a rangeVoice identified at 5 of 40 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking0.1 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.0 to 0.5 minutes, over 40 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.2 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Seth BrenzelCommissioner0.5min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 13 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking0.5 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.3 to 1.1 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.31 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Two of their clips
One is I had a question about just seating at the baseball— seating. Where do people watch the games? Like bleachers and stands?”
Patrick CarneyArchitecture · Commissioner2.6min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 18 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking2.6 min of talk time a meeting90% range 1.6 to 4.3 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.32 questions asked
Their top topics
Parks and recreation10%
Share of the time they spoke, by topic. Only topics that passed our check.Three of their clips
I’ve received small grants, you know, grants for the arts for $1,000 and then one for $10,000, and I used Excel spreadsheets. I don’t have QuickBooks. And, you know, the stringent requirements, is there some flexibility for the smaller grant recipients in their reporting?”
So the jump, jump from the top of the fence onto the roof is very easy. And you said it’s a high-security area. There’s no razor wire or barbed wire up there?”
Suzanne FerrasVisual Arts · Commissioner4.8min of talk time a meeting1–5 of 12place in talk time, as a rangeVoice identified at 26 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking4.8 min of talk time a meeting90% range 3.3 to 8.3 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.31 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Three of their clips
So the 25-year fade-free guarantee, what happens after 25 years and it starts to fade?”
Are there templates and things that you’re providing the artists and the organizations for reporting templates for the documentation so that they already have— this is how it needs to be reported, these are the sections?”
Let’s say one of the private sector partners wants to do these things but is not really like aware of what organizations there are that they should be reaching out to, is SFAC able to provide like, you know, these are the different districts, these are different organizations, maybe reach out to these folks?”
Nabiel MuslehVisual Arts · Commissioner0.8min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 14 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking0.8 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.4 to 1.4 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.23 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Two of their clips
I’m just wondering about the your IG, when you’re putting all this information out and calling out people to come and join the live and all that, is that going through the main IG messaging?”
Al PerezArts · Arts commissioner1.1min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 21 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking1.1 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.7 to 1.8 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.74 questions asked
Their top topics
Arts, culture and libraries82%
Parks and recreation6%
Development and land use3%
Share of the time they spoke, by topic. Only topics that passed our check.Three of their clips
Does that mean all grants will be 2 years, it takes 2 years to reimburse, or can there be some grants that can be done in 1 year?”
I think this is a great program for artists that are looking to get into public works and also getting into understanding how to navigate arts organizations and things of that nature, how to apply, how to present your work, how to structure, how to get client-artist relationships down.”
McKenna QuintArts · Arts commissioner0.5min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 15 of 43 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking0.5 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.3 to 1.0 minutes, over 43 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.22 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Three of their clips
…you remind me how many individuals you think will be working in the 2 offices that are adjacent to the landscaped area? Do you know about how many that is?”
…is there any part of the process within the Arts Commission to look at the percentage of income that is coming from our grants versus external fundraising, board contributions, et cetera?”
Jessica RothschildArchitecture · Commissioner1.2min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 10 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking1.2 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.5 to 2.6 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.49 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Marcus Anthony ShelbyPerforming Arts (Music) · Commissioner0.7min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 7 of 36 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking0.7 min of talk time a meeting90% range 0.3 to 1.6 minutes, over 36 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.16 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Janine ShiotaPerforming Arts & Literary Arts · Commission vice president2.9min of talk time a meetingIn the same talk-time range as most of the 12 members comparedVoice identified at 22 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking2.9 min of talk time a meeting90% range 1.9 to 4.2 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.31 questions asked
Their top topicsNo checked topic mix for this member here yet.
Three of their clips
Can you explain what the cost of doing business funds— what that designation is? I just haven’t seen it before.”
The $156,000 that is going offsite for the art enrichment, is it going to stay in Lake Merced or is it going to Yeah, where is— is there a plan for it?”
Debra WalkerVisual Arts · Commissioner5.1min of talk time a meeting1–5 of 12place in talk time, as a rangeVoice identified at 30 of 44 transcribed meetings while seated
AttendanceThe clerk’s roll calls for this body aren’t in our record.
Speaking5.1 min of talk time a meeting90% range 4.0 to 6.7 minutes, over 44 meetings held while seated. Counts only speech we can attribute by voice, so it can undercount.55 questions asked
Their top topics
Arts, culture and libraries93%
Development and land use<1%
Share of the time they spoke, by topic. Only topics that passed our check.Two of their clips
…the certification process, does that last a lifetime? I mean, one of the things that sometimes we discuss as a community is if people aren’t doing their art anymore, if they’ve given up, you know, is it then just housing or how do we deal with that?”













