Julie Menin
The speaker, District 5, New York City CouncilRaised ICE and immigration enforcement at three meetings. Named Manhattan most often: two times.
Next New York City Council meeting: Thu, Nov 12, 1:30 pm · Agenda
District 5 on the current New York City Council map
Every roll call, and Menin’s other bodies
Present at 23 of 23 roll calls at the New York City Council
- New York City Council: talk time not compared. Ran some of its meetings, so isn’t compared with the members.
- Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection: talk time not compared. Listed on the roster as Chair, so isn’t compared with the members.
- Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection: present at 5 of 5 roll calls. Official roll call, from the clerk
- Committee on Civil Service and Labor: present at 4 of 4 roll calls. Official roll call, from the clerk
- Committee on Health: present at 2 of 5 roll calls. Official roll call, from the clerk
- Committee on Parks and Recreation: present at 2 of 3 roll calls. Official roll call, from the clerk
- Committee on Rules, Privileges and Elections: present at 1 of 1 roll calls. Official roll call, from the clerk
- Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management: present at 1 of 2 roll calls. Official roll call, from the clerk
6 places Menin named in meetings
- Manhattan 2 times
- Queens 2 times
- Staten Island 2 times
- Borough Park 1 time
- Brooklyn 1 time
- Midtown 1 time
Every meeting where we identified Menin’s voice
- Sep 24, 2026New York City Council10.3 min10:07
- Sep 10, 2026New York City Council14.5 min16:46
- Aug 13, 2026New York City Council19.5 min21:10
- Jun 30, 2026New York City Council20.0 min4:12
- Jun 11, 2026New York City Council20.0 min8:20
- May 14, 2026New York City Council7.8 minVideo
- Apr 30, 2026New York City Council13.1 min12:29
- Apr 16, 2026New York City Council17.6 min19:11
- Mar 10, 2026New York City Council10.7 min14:07
- Feb 24, 2026New York City Council13.5 min11:01
Show all 20Show fewer
- Feb 12, 2026New York City Council15.5 min10:06
- Jan 29, 2026New York City Council15.8 min9:04
- Jan 7, 2026New York City Council23.1 min1:22:00
- Dec 18, 2025New York City Council1.0 min2:02:28
- Dec 18, 2025Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection4.7 min0:13
- Nov 25, 2025New York City Council1.3 min12:43
- Nov 12, 2025New York City Council1.6 min32:13
- Oct 30, 2025Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection12.7 min17:17
- Oct 29, 2025New York City Council0.1 min15:29
- Oct 29, 2025Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection2.6 min0:29
How we identify who is speaking · blind check, pooled across five cities: of 410 council lines drawn, 352 right, 0 wrong, 1 unclear, 57 couldn’t be judged
We identified Menin’s voice at 20 meetings across two bodies. A meeting missing here means we couldn’t attribute the voice, not that Menin was absent. Claude and Gemini each read every transcript with that day’s roster. A voice gets Julie Menin’s name only when both agree and a code check finds the name said on, or just before, their turn. Voices our transcripts merge with someone else’s are never attributed, so every count here undercounts what Menin said. For councils and their committees, of 410 lines drawn, 352 were right, 0 wrong and 1 unclear, and the checkers couldn’t judge 57. We have since removed the voices behind 110 of those lines (0 wrong, 1 unclear, the rest we had already held for other reasons). Of the 300 lines we still publish, the checkers could judge 268: all 268 right (90% lower bound 0.99). They couldn’t judge the other 32. The check is one sample pooled across the five cities, not of Menin or of New York alone.